Explore vegetables.im

Myths versus facts

Twelve claims, and what the official pages actually say

None of these myths is a straw man invented to make the desk look busy. Each one is a tidy sentence a careful reader might walk away with, if official wording were blended, or treated as all one voice.

Myth. The shops and the garden mean the same thing by broccoli.

The official pages say: The Royal Horticultural Society treats them as two crops. Its broccoli guide is about sprouting broccoli: small clusters of usually purple buds on long, leafy stems. The large green head often sold as broccoli is, in the Society’s gardening sense, calabrese.

Myth. Calabrese is just another word the RHS uses for sprouting broccoli.

The official pages say: The calabrese guide says the two “are two different crops, but they are often muddled up.” Plants, seasons and cutting rules are given separately, and this desk keeps them separate.

Myth. A large supermarket head cannot officially be called broccoli at all.

The official pages say: The Society itself says that large head is “confusingly often called broccoli in supermarkets and recipes.” Encyclopaedia Britannica’s official broccoli page describes a plant grown for its edible flower buds and stalk, without spending the page on the British garden distinction. Official wording is not all one way.

Myth. The Italica Group profile proves the two growing guides should be read as one crop.

The official pages say: The profile lists calabrese and sprouting broccoli among other common names, and then points gardeners to “broccoli cultivation or calabrese cultivation.” The name-list is not used here to flatten the two guides.

Myth. Purple sprouting broccoli stays purple when cooked.

The official pages say: The Society’s broccoli guide says: “Purple varieties generally turn green when cooked.”

Myth. There is one official height for broccoli.

The official pages say: The calabrese guide gives up to 60cm. The broccoli guide gives traditional plants up to 90cm. Encyclopaedia Britannica gives 60–90 cm. The Italica Group profile gives a maximum height of 1–1.5 metres. Those official figures are not averaged.

Myth. There is one official number of days from sowing to harvest.

The official pages say: Britannica gives 60 to 150 days. The calabrese guide gives three or four months. The broccoli guide gives four to ten months to start cropping, and says traditional plants can take eight months or more to mature. The profile gives time to maturity as 1 year.

Myth. Side-shoots on calabrese last for one official span, neatly stated once.

The official pages say: The same official calabrese page says they extend the harvest “for up to eight weeks,” and later “for up to a couple of months.” Both wordings are kept.

Myth. If you leave the head on the plant, nothing official happens except that it spoils.

The official pages say: Encyclopaedia Britannica says unharvested buds “bear yellow flowers with four petals and produce silique fruits (a dry capsule).”

Myth. Broccoli is officially native to Britain and Ireland.

The official pages say: The Italica Group profile, under Native to GB/Ireland, says No. Encyclopaedia Britannica says it is native to the eastern Mediterranean and Asia Minor, and that sprouting broccoli was cultivated in Italy in ancient Roman times and introduced to England and America in the 1700s.

Myth. Encyclopaedia Britannica and the RHS agree that the plant is an annual.

The official pages say: Britannica calls it “a fast-growing annual plant.” The Society’s profile calls it “a semi-evergreen, biennial plant grown as an annual/biennial vegetable.” Both official wordings are kept.

Myth. This site is an official RHS or Britannica page.

The official pages say: It is independent, and is not affiliated with or endorsed by the Royal Horticultural Society or Encyclopaedia Britannica. Official wording is quoted from the pages listed in the sources.

Keep the lights on

Enjoyed this desk of two official growing guides that refuse to be one crop?

No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next vegetables.im site get built.